Why Most Productivity Systems Make You Worse at Your Job

I have a confession. I spent years building the perfect productivity system. I tried GTD. I tried Kanban boards. I tried Inbox Zero. I tried combining all three. Every few months I would find a new tool, migrate everything over, and feel that brief rush of control.

Then reality would set in.

The system would grow. The lists would multiply. I would spend more time maintaining my productivity system than actually being productive. Sound familiar?

Here is what I eventually realized: the problem was never the system. The problem was the assumption underneath every system I tried. They all assumed that the goal was to manage more. Track more. Organize more. Capture everything. Let nothing slip through the cracks.

But what if most of what slips through the cracks doesn’t matter?

The Hidden Cost of Tracking Everything

Every item you track has a cost. Not just the time to enter it, but the ongoing cognitive weight of knowing it exists. Your brain does not distinguish between a critical deliverable and a “maybe someday” idea sitting in your backlog. Both take up space. Both create a low hum of obligation.

This is why you can have a perfectly organized system and still feel overwhelmed. Organization does not reduce load. It just makes the load tidier.

Think about your current system right now. How many items are in it? How many of those items have been sitting there for more than two weeks? More than a month? How many of them, if you are being honest, would have zero consequences if they simply disappeared?

If you are like most people, the answer is uncomfortable. A significant chunk of what you are tracking does not need to be tracked. You are spending real mental energy maintaining awareness of things that do not matter.

The Elimination Alternative

This is the core idea behind Nix It: instead of finding better ways to manage more, focus on reducing how much you have to hold.

It is built on two principles that sound almost too simple.

The first is that elimination is safe. You can remove things with confidence because important things come back. Think about how often something you forgot about actually resurfaced on its own, through a follow-up email, a colleague asking about it, or simply coming back to mind at the right time. The things that matter have a way of persisting. The things that do not matter quietly disappear, and nobody notices.

The second principle is that clarity is strength. The less you hold, the clearer your thinking. Every item you drop from your system is not just one fewer thing to manage. It is space recovered for the things that actually deserve your attention.

What This Looks Like in Practice

Nix It operates through three stages: Filter, Distill, and Eliminate.

When something enters your world, whether it is an email, a task from a meeting, a Slack message, or your own idea, the first question is not “where should I put this?” The first question is “what happens if I don’t track this at all?” If the answer is nothing meaningful, you eliminate it right there. It never enters your system. It never takes up space.

For the items that do make the cut, they move onto a canvas where you can see and manage them. But even here, the system is designed to reduce what you see at any given moment. Items are organized by who owns the next action (you, someone else, or an event that has not happened yet), and most of them are hidden from view until a trigger surfaces them.

The final stage is elimination itself. Every item’s destination is removal from the system, either by completing it or by deciding it no longer matters. Both exits are equally valid. The system draws no distinction between them.

And then there is the weekly review, which is less about making sure nothing was missed and more about challenging every item’s right to exist. The older something is, the more justification it needs to keep taking up space.

Why This Works

Traditional productivity systems optimize for capture. They are afraid of losing things. Their worst-case scenario is that something important falls through the cracks.

Nix It optimizes for clarity. Its worst-case scenario is that you are carrying too much. And here is the thing: if something important does get eliminated, it comes back. Someone follows up. A deadline reasserts itself. Your own memory resurfaces it. Important things are resilient.

Unimportant things, on the other hand, are fragile. They cannot survive being questioned. And that is exactly the point. By making elimination the default rather than the exception, you naturally filter down to the work that actually matters.

Getting Started

You do not need a tool to start practicing this. You can start right now.

Open whatever system you currently use. Look at your list of tasks, your project boards, your email folders. For each item, ask yourself: what happens if I delete this right now? If the honest answer is “probably nothing,” delete it. Do not archive it. Do not move it to a “someday” list. Remove it.

Notice how that feels. If it felt like relief, you were carrying too much.

Nix It exists to make this process structured and sustainable. It gives you a place to hold the things that genuinely need holding, while making elimination the easiest and most natural action at every step.

Because the goal was never to manage everything. The goal was always to hold less and do better.

---

Nix It is a work management system that prioritizes elimination over organization. Learn more and try it free.